Articles

FDI: Is investing in Pakistan attractive?

Syed Muhammad Ijaz

The issue of attracting foreign direct investment (FDI) for Pakistan has assumed renewed importance in the wake of serious crunch in foreign exchange reserves and huge external payments. Since the establishment of Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) through Board of Investment (Amendment) Act 2023, there has been expectations in all circles that Memorandum of Understanding (MOUs) signed through its efforts would be materialized. However, empirical data shows that due to unfavourable circumstances, perpetual political instability leading to economic uncertainty, the foreign investors are reluctant to make any long-term commitments in Pakistan, especially when local investors are disillusioned and shying away from new outlays.

Though there are many negative perceptions about the country at the moment, the one very important factor is usually ignored or not discussed: the complexities of the taxation system, over regulations, and above all low return on capital (because of highly devalued currency and instability). Realistically speaking, the investment on merit and comparative perspective is not at all attractive in Pakistan under the prevailing circumstances. In this article, a hypothetical case study is presented to highlight only one point that is low-yield on investment in dollar terms from the United States. It also suggests the remedial measures to overcome this impediment. Needless to emphasize that unless structural reforms are undertaken, the present scenario will continue creating more difficult times for a country of now around 250 million people—the fifth largest populated nation with forty-first position in 2022 and forty-third in 2023  in world economy.

Hypothetical Case Study

Assume a US-based investor commits USD 100 million to Pakistan with the expectation of achieving a 10% rate of return upon exit after five years. The following key assumptions apply:

Exchange Rate Projections (PKR/USD)

Based on historical data, the Pakistani rupee (PKR) has depreciated at an average annual rate of 10%. For this analysis, we assume the following exchange rates:

Date Exchange Rate (PKR/USD)
01-01-2025 278.78
31-12-2025 280.00
31-12-2026 308.00
31-12-2027 338.80
31-12-2028 372.68
31-12-2029 409.95

Taxation Assumptions in Pakistan

  • Dividend Tax Rate: 15.0%
  • Capital Gains Tax Rate: 29.0%
  • Corporate Tax Rate (Normal Tax Regime): 29.0%

Required Rate of Return in Pakistan versus the US

To match the expected return on investment in the US market (12%), an investment in Pakistan must generate significantly higher returns to compensate for currency depreciation and taxation. The required rates are as follows:

Pakistan

  • Pre-Tax Return in Pakistan: 23.9%
  • Post-Tax Return in Pakistan: 17.0%

US

For comparison, the benchmark US bank rate (assuming a 1.5% spread) is 7.5% while US market rate of return is 12%.

Taxation Under the US-Pakistan Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTA)

Under Article VI, Paragraphs (1) and (2) of the DTA, dividends paid by private limited companies in Pakistan to US holding companies are not covered, making them taxable in Pakistan at the standard 15% rate.

Similarly, capital gains are not covered under the DTA, and thus, the situs rule applies, meaning they remain taxable under Pakistani tax law.

Investment Returns Comparison: US versus Pakistan

US-Based Investment

A USD 100 million investment in the US at a 12% annual return will grow to USD 176.2 million by 31-12-2029.

Pakistan-Based Investment

  1. Currency Depreciation Impact:
  • Initial investment: USD 100M
  • PKR depreciation results in an exchange loss of USD 32M, reducing the investment’s real value to USD 68M at exit.
  1. Dividend Income Over Five Years:
  • Gross dividends: USD 70.5M
  • Tax (15%): USD 10.5M
  • Net dividends received: USD 60.0M
  1. Capital Gain at Exit:
  • Gross capital gain: USD 68M
  • Tax (29%): USD 19.72M
  • Net capital gain: USD 48.28M
  1. Total Return (Net of Tax in USD):
  • USD 176.2M, equivalent to the US-based investment’s return.

Key Question: Why Invest in Pakistan?

Given that an investment in Pakistan yields the same post-tax return as investing in the US, the question arises: why would a US investor take on additional risk by investing in Pakistan?

To make Pakistan an attractive destination, returns must exceed US-based returns to justify the higher risk premium. A mere 2% increase in required returns over the US benchmark would necessitate a:

  • Pre-tax return of 30.4%
  • Post-tax return of 21.6%

Additionally, any further acceleration in PKR depreciation beyond 10% annually would further complicate the viability of FDI in Pakistan.

Non-Financial Risks: The Final Barrier to FDI

Beyond financial factors, non-financial risks further discourage FDI in Pakistan. These include:

  1. Political Instability – Frequent regime changes with no certainty of completing the tenure provided in the supreme law of the land—Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
  2. Uncertain policies—abrupt changes even by the same government, with complete lack of continuity on change or regimes.
  3. Weak Judiciary & Lack of Justice – Legal unpredictability undermines investor confidence.
  4. De Facto Rulers & Bureaucratic Red Tape – Non-elected power structures and excessive regulations create hurdles.
  5. Corruption – Rampant subornment, rent-seeking and lack of transparency deter investors.
  6. 6. Harsh Tax Policies by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) – The FBR’s aggressive stance towards foreign investors adds another layer of risk.

Conclusion: Is Pakistan an Attractive Investment Destination?

While Pakistan offers potential high returns, its currency devaluation, taxation policies, and political instability create substantial investment risks. Without significant structural reforms and investor-friendly policies, Pakistan may keep on struggling to attract serious foreign investors.

For attracting FDI, Pakistan must:

  • Ensure currency stability to reduce exchange rate risks.
  • Offer competitive tax incentives to compensate for higher risks.
  • Improve governance and legal transparency to build investor confidence.
  • Reform the FBR to make it facilitation-oriented agency and change its approach (mindset) towards foreign investments to remove bureaucratic hurdles and undue litigation.

Until such reforms materialize, foreign investors are unlikely to opt for Pakistan, as they will always opt for safer and more predictable markets like the United States and many others countries, where similar returns can be achieved with lower risk exposure.

 

Syed Muhammad Ijaz, FCA (ICAP), ACA (ICAEW), LL.B, partner of Huzaima & Ikram, has over 25 years of expertise in finance, tax, and corporate law and is dedicated to making noteworthy contributions to Pakistan’s financial and legal fields

 

More Similar Posts

Detonating POL bomb  

  Huzaima Bukhari & Dr. Ikramul Haq Rising need of petroleum and its heavy taxation leaves the common man stripped of his earnings, and renders…
Most Viewed Posts

Economy in Distress

Economy in distress Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori The gargantuan challenges faced by Pakistan’s economy are the outcomes of continuous mismanagement and bad…

World Bank on tax reforms

World Bank & tax reforms Huzaima Bukhari & Dr. Ikramul Haq The World Bank in an appraisal paper related to Pakistan Raises Revenue (PRR) Project…