“Article”

Appeasing the bazaar again

Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori When Pakistan's tax history is eventually written, one recurring theme will stand out above all others: governments of every political persuasion have found it easier to impose heavier taxes on documented businesses, salaried employees and consumers than to integrate the country's powerful trading community into the normal tax system. The Federal Board of Revenue's draft Special Procedure for Small Shopkeepers, issued under section 99B of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, is the latest illustration of this enduring pattern rather than a genuine tax reform. The proposal is being portrayed as a measure to broaden documentation and facilitate voluntary compliance. In reality, it establishes a parallel tax regime based not on sound principles of taxation but on political accommodation. Instead of integrating retailers into the ordinary income tax system, it grants them concessions that are unavailable to virtually every other class of taxpayer. The first conceptual flaw lies in its definition of a "small shopkeeper". The proposed scheme covers individual retailers having annual turnover of up to Rs. 200 million. Such businesses can hardly be described as small enterprises. Depending upon the nature of trade, a retailer with annual sales approaching Rs. 200 million may generate substantial taxable income. International experience demonstrates that simplified tax regimes are generally confined to genuinely micro and small enterprises. Pakistan, however, has chosen to extend preferential treatment to businesses of considerable economic size. This threshold will inevitably encourage fragmentation of businesses and artificial suppression of turnover in order to remain eligible for the concession. Equally problematic is the voluntary nature of the scheme. A retailer may either opt into the special procedure or continue under the ordinary provisions of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. Tax systems are founded upon neutrality and horizontal equity. Persons engaged in identical economic activities should not be permitted to select whichever tax regime yields the lowest liability. Optional taxation inevitably produces arbitrage rather than compliance. The proposal taxes retailers at one per cent of gross turnover while permitting adjustment of withholding taxes but denying any refund if withholding exceeds the tax payable. Income tax is designed to tax net income after deducting legitimate business expenditure. Turnover taxation may serve as a minimum tax in exceptional cases, but it cannot become a substitute for determining taxable income. The proposed mechanism therefore departs from one of the most fundamental principles of income taxation-the taxation of real income according to ability to pay-under this ratil taxation has US$15 billion potential! The draft is even more remarkable in relation to tax administration. Retailers opting for the scheme would generally not be subject to audit. Departmental proceedings may only be initiated after consultation with representatives of trade associations and only where there is third-party information regarding unusual transactions, expensive assets or gross misuse of the procedure. No comparable statutory privilege exists for companies, manufacturers, exporters, banks, professionals or salaried taxpayers. Audit is a sovereign function of tax administration. Making its exercise contingent upon consultation with private trade associations compromises the independence of revenue administration and creates an unprecedented class of privileged taxpayers. The concessions do not end there. Participants are exempted from withholding obligations under section 153, relieved from the ordinary minimum tax provisions and, most significantly, exempted from installation of sales tax POS systems or digital invoicing infrastructure. This concession fundamentally contradicts the government's repeated claim that digitalisation constitutes the cornerstone of tax reform. If digital invoicing is indispensable for documenting the economy, why should one of the largest segments of Pakistan's retail sector be exempted from precisely that requirement? The proposal goes even further by introducing a "Green Plate" carrying an FBR-issued QR code. Shops displaying this plate would ordinarily be free from visits by FBR officials in tax matters. Compliance in modern tax systems is established through proper books of account, verifiable invoices, digital transaction trails and risk-based audits-not by displaying official plaques outside business premises. Viewed collectively, these provisions establish a separate tax universe for organised traders. Manufacturers remain subject to electronic invoicing, extensive withholding obligations, advance taxation, minimum taxes, detailed documentation requirements and routine audits. Banks serve as withholding agents for dozens of taxes. Salaried employees have their taxes deducted before they receive their salaries. Retailers alone are offered voluntary taxation, simplified returns, immunity from routine audits and exemption from digital documentation. This asymmetry raises serious questions of tax justice. Horizontal equity requires that taxpayers with comparable economic capacity should bear comparable legal obligations. Pakistan's fiscal structure increasingly moves in the opposite direction. Compliance obligations expand for documented sectors while politically organised groups negotiate exemptions from the very mechanisms that constitute modern tax administration. The proposal also exposes an uncomfortable inconsistency in the implementation of Pakistan's IMF-supported fiscal programme. The government has repeatedly maintained that it cannot grant general sales tax (GST) relief on socially essential goods such as stationery, educational supplies and other items used by students because broad-based exemptions would violate commitments to preserve the integrity of the tax base. Consequently, millions of households continue paying eighteen per cent GST on goods directly related to education and health etc. At the same time, a highly concessionary regime is proposed for retailers with annual turnover up to Rs. 200 million, allowing optional participation, concessional taxation, exemption from digital invoicing and significant protection from audit. Whether these concessions were specifically discussed with the IMF or merely tolerated by it is beside the point. The inconsistency is unmistakable. Fiscal discipline appears uncompromising when schoolchildren, salaried households and ordinary consumers bear the burden of indirect taxation. It becomes remarkably flexible when politically organised trader groups demand preferential treatment. Such asymmetry inevitably weakens public confidence in both domestic tax policy and externally supported fiscal reforms. Nor will consumers ultimately benefit. A retailer paying tax at one per cent of turnover is unlikely to absorb that burden. It will simply become another component of the selling price, passed on to the final consumer. Thus, instead of broadening the tax base, the proposal merely redistributes the incidence of taxation while leaving the structural weaknesses of Pakistan's retail economy untouched. Pakistan does not require another negotiated settlement with trader organisations. It requires a coherent retail tax policy based on universally applicable principles: compulsory registration, mandatory digital invoicing, integration with banking and payment systems, transparent risk-based audit selection, low and predictable tax rates and a genuine value-added tax that preserves the input tax chain from manufacturer to retailer. Simplification of compliance is both desirable and necessary, but simplification must never become exemption from the ordinary rule of law. The draft 'Special Procedure for Small Shopkeepers' is therefore not a milestone (sic) in tax reform. It is another reminder that Pakistan's tax policy continues to be shaped less by constitutional principles and sound economics than by the relative bargaining power of organised interest groups. Until this political economy changes, genuine tax reform will remain elusive, documentation will remain incomplete and the burden of financing the state will continue to fall upon those who are already visible, documented and least able to negotiate special treatment. _____________________________________________________________ Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, specializes in constitutional, corporate, environment, media, ML/CFT related laws, IT, intellectual property, arbitration and international tax laws. He holds an LLD in tax laws with specialization in transfer pricing. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996. He established Huzaima & Ikram in 1996 and is presently its chief partner. He studied journalism, English literature and law. He is Chief Editor of Taxation. He is country editor and correspondent of International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation (IBFD) and member of International Fiscal Association (IFA). He is Visiting Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) and member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). He has coauthored with Huzaima Bukhari many books that include, Tax Reforms in Pakistan: Historic & Critical Review, Towards Broad, Flat, Low-rate, and Predictable Taxes (third edition, 2024), Pakistan: Enigma of Taxation, Towards Flat, Low-rate, Broad and Predictable Taxes (revised/enlarged edition of December 2020), Law & Practice of Income Tax, Law , Practice of Sales Tax, Law and Practice of Corporate Law, Law & Practice of Federal Excise, Law & Practice of Sales Tax on Services, Federal Tax Laws of Pakistan, Provincial Tax Laws, Practical Handbook of Income Tax, Tax Laws of Pakistan, Principles of Income Tax with Glossary and Master Tax Guide, Income Tax Digest 1886-2011 (with judicial analysis). He is author of Commentary on Avoidance of Double Taxation Agreements, Pakistan: From Hash to Heroin, its sequel Pakistan: Drug-trap to Debt-trap and Practical Handbook of Income Tax. Two books of poetry are Phull Kikkaran De (Punjabi 2023) and Nai Ufaq (Urdu 1979 with Siraj Munir and Shahid Jamal). He regularly writes columns/article/papers for many Pakistani newspapers and international journals and has contributed over 3000 articles on a variety of issues of public interest, printed in various journals, magazines and newspapers at home and abroad. _______________________________________________________________ Abdul Rauf Shakoori, Advocate High Court, is a subject-matter expert on AML-CFT, Compliance, Cyber Crime and Risk Management. He has been providing AML-CFT advisory and training services to financial institutions (banks, DNFBPs, Investment companies, Money Service Businesses, insurance companies and securities), government institutions including law enforcement agencies located in North America (USA & CANADA), Middle East and Pakistan. His areas of expertise include legal, strategic planning, cross-border transactions including but not limited to joint ventures (JVs), mergers & acquisitions (M&A), takeovers, privatizations, overseas expansions, USA Patriot Act, Banking Secrecy Act, Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC). Over his career he has demonstrated excellent leadership, communication, analytical, and problem-solving skills and have also developed and delivered training courses in the areas of AML/CFT, Compliance, Fraud & Financial Crime Risk Management, Bank Secrecy, Cyber Crimes & Internet Threats against Banks, E-Channels Fraud Prevention, Security and Investigation of Financial Crimes. The courses have been delivered as practical workshops with case study driven scenarios and exams to ensure knowledge transfer. His notable publications are Rauf's Compilation of Corporate Laws of Pakistan, Rauf's Company Law and Practice of Pakistan and Rauf's Research on Labour Laws and Income Tax and others. His articles include: Revenue collection: Contemporary targets vs. orthodox approach, It is time to say goodbye to our past, US double standards, Was Due Process Flouted While Convicting Nawaz Sharif?, FATF and unjustly grey listed Pakistan, Corruption is no excuse for Incompetence, Next step for Pakistan, Pakistan's compliance with FATF mandates, a work in progress, Pakistan's strategy to address FATF Mandates was Inadequate, Pakistan's Evolving FATF Compliance, Transparency Curtails Corruption, Pakistan's Long Road towards FATF Compliance, Pakistan's Archaic Approach to Addressing FATF Mandates, FATF: Challenges for June deadline, Pakistan: Combating the illicit flow of money, Regulating Crypto: An uphill task for Pakistan. Pakistan's economy – Chicanery of numbers. Pakistan: Reclaiming its space on FATF whitelist. Sacred Games: Kulbhushan Jadhav Case. National FATF secretariat and Financial Monitoring Unit. The FATF challenge. Pakistan: Crucial FATF hearing. Pakistan: Dissecting FATF Failure, Environmental crimes: An emerging challenge, Countering corrupt practices . The recent publication, coauthored by these writes with Huzaima Bukhari is: Pakistan Tackling FATF: Challenges & Solutions, available at: https://aacp.com.pk/book-detail/pakistan-tackling-fatf-challenges-and-solutions-35 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08RXH8W46

Related analysis

More Similar Posts

Budget 2027 & challenges-I

Debtocracy & Pakistan’s lost sovereignty Dr. Ikramul Haq “?.PPP’s Senator Raza Rabbani, a noted lawyer and former chairman of the Senate, termed the IMF the…

When VAT ceases to be VAT-III

Rebuilding the invoice-credit chain Dr Ikramul Haq Pakistan does not need another sales-tax reform package. It needs a decision: either restore VAT’s…

Most Viewed Posts

Reckless borrowing spree

Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori Pakistan’s economy is facing a severe and multifaceted crisis due to fiscal instability, a fragile currency, and an…

Indian Budget 2025-26

Huzaima Bukhari, Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori   The Indian economy, despite its resilience and potential, faces a multitude of challenges as it…

Massive funding plans

Huzaima Bukhari, Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori   The Foreign Economic Assistance Monthly Report for November 2024 published by the Ministry of Economic…