“Article”

Digital Due Process under Articles 4 & 10A

Constitutional Limits of Faceless Tax Administration under the Finance Act, 2026 Keynote Address All Pakistan Tax Bar Association | Serena Hotel, Islamabad | 23 July 2026 Dr. Ikramul Haq Advocate Supreme Court of Pakistan "For the determination of his civil rights and obligations or in any criminal charge against him a person shall be entitled to a fair trial and due process." – Article 10A, Constitution of Pakistan

Opening Honourable chief guest, learned speakers and members of the Pakistan Tax Bar Association, distinguished tax professionals, officers of the tax administration, ladies and gentlemen. It is a privilege to speak at the All Pakistan Tax Bar gathering on a subject that is no longer merely technical. It is constitutional. It is institutional. It concerns the future relationship between the citizen and the State in the digital age. My topic is 'Article 10A of the Constitution and faceless tax proceedings'. Article 10A says in clear and solemn words that, "For the determination of his civil rights and obligations or in any criminal charge against him a person shall be entitled to a fair trial and due process". In taxation, the determination of civil rights and obligations is not an abstract phrase. It means assessment, audit, recovery, penalty, prosecution, cancellation of registration, disallowance of input tax, freezing of assets, and every other fiscal consequence that directly affects property, business, reputation and liberty. The Finance Act, 2026 has introduced a new administrative structure. It is being presented as a reform designed to reduce physical contact between taxpayers, their authorised representatives and tax officers. No one can deny that unnecessary physical contact has often produced rent-seeking, pressure, harassment and corruption. Technology can certainly reduce discretion. It can speed up compliance. It can help detect patterns which human officers may miss. But technology is not a constitutional value in itself. It becomes legitimate only when it operates within the limits of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan-the supreme law of the land. The Constitution comes first We must therefore begin not with the Finance Act, but with the Constitution. Article 4 guarantees the right of every person to be dealt with in accordance with law. Article 10A guarantees fair trial and due process. Article 14 protects dignity and privacy. Article 19A secures the right to have access to information in matters of public importance, subject to regulation and reasonable restrictions imposed by law. Articles 23 and 24 protect property. When these provisions are read together, they create a constitutional framework for tax administration. The State may tax, but it must tax by law. It may investigate, but it must investigate lawfully. It may collect information, but it must not convert information into secret power. It may use algorithms, but algorithms cannot become a substitute for accountable adjudication. The old language of due process was notice, hearing, disclosure of material, impartial decision-maker, reasoned order and judicial review. The new language of the digital State is data collection, data integration, data analytics, profiling, algorithmic selection, e-hearing, faceless jurisdiction and automated settlement. The constitutional question before us is simple: does Article 10A protect the citizen only at the last stage when an order is passed, or does it also protect the citizen throughout the digital process by which the order is generated? My respectful submission is that Article 10A protects the entire process. Jubilee Insurance and due process This is not a foreign idea. It already exists in our jurisprudence. In New Jubilee Insurance Company Ltd v National Bank of Pakistan [PLD 1999 Supreme Court 1126], the Supreme Court held that there are basic norms of justice, that no one can be a judge in his own cause, and that breach of such cardinal principles violates the right of access to justice enshrined in Article 4. The Court explained that the right of access to justice includes the right to be treated according to law, the right to have a fair and proper trial, and the right to have an impartial court or tribunal. This is a direct constitutional bridge between Article 4 and due process. It is also the answer to those who say that taxation is only an administrative matter. Taxation is undoubtedly a sovereign function, but the exercise of sovereign power is precisely where constitutional discipline is most needed. Other leading tax cases reinforce the same principle. In CIT, East Pakistan v Aswab Ali [1975) 31 Tax 101 (SC)], the Supreme Court held that no person can be subjected to an obligation without being afforded an opportunity to show cause. In CIT, East Pakistan v Fazlur Rahman and Saeedur Rahman [(1964) 10 Tax 49 (SC)], the Court held that the absence of an express provision for notice cannot override the principle of natural justice where rights are affected. These principles are not decorative. They are controlling. They apply to judicial and quasi-judicial proceedings, and tax proceedings are certainly proceedings where civil obligations are determined. What Finance Act, 2026 introduces The Finance Act, 2026 has inserted provisions for faceless proceedings in all major federal tax laws. In customs, section 179(6) authorises faceless adjudication without face-to-face interaction between the adjudicating officer and the respondent. In sales tax, new section 11H introduces faceless audit and assessment; section 30AA creates faceless jurisdiction; section 32C establishes the National Faceless Centre; section 45C provides for faceless appeals; and section 47AA introduces algorithmic settlement. In income tax, corresponding provisions include section 122E for faceless audit and assessment, section 129A for faceless appeals, section 134B for algorithmic settlement, section 209B for faceless jurisdiction, and section 227D for the National Faceless Centre. Federal excise law is also brought within the same architecture through application of the National Faceless Centre and algorithmic settlement mechanism. The structure is important. Jurisdiction may be assigned through algorithms developed by the Board. The National Faceless Centre may exercise exclusive or concurrent jurisdiction. Physical verification may also be allocated through an algorithm-based system. The identity of the authority exercising jurisdiction in the National Faceless Centre is to be kept confidential from the taxpayer and the authorised representative. Communications are to be electronic. Settlement offers may be generated digitally on the basis of compliance history, discrepancy profile, stage of proceedings and any other basis considered relevant by the Board. Even more significant is the new Central Data Hub mechanism in section 165AB of the Income Tax Ordinance. Banking companies and electronic money institutions are required to upload information to a virtual repository maintained through PRAL for algorithmic cross-matching of tax and bank information. Where there is a gross mismatch, the system feeds the information into the Compliance Risk Management system and proceedings move to the National Faceless Centre. The central constitutional difficulty This is the point at which the constitutional concern becomes unavoidable. We are not discussing a simple electronic filing system. We are discussing a technological ecosystem in which personal, financial and transactional data are collected, uploaded, processed, cross-matched, profiled and used for initiating proceedings that may culminate in adverse civil consequences. In such a system, due process cannot mean only that a notice appears on IRIS. Due process must mean that the taxpayer knows what material has been used, from which source it was obtained, how it was processed, who had access to it, whether an algorithm materially influenced the decision, and whether a human authority independently applied its mind before issuing an adverse order. Without these safeguards, digital administration can become more opaque than physical administration. A faceless system reduces physical contact. But if it also hides identity, hides reasoning, hides data sources and hides algorithmic criteria, then facelessness becomes constitutional darkness. The taxpayer is no longer dealing with an officer whose jurisdiction can be examined, whose conduct can be questioned, and whose reasoning can be tested. The taxpayer is dealing with a digital and blind wall. Personal data and informational due process My central proposition today is that Article 10A must now be interpreted to include what I would call informational due process. In the digital regulatory State, fair trial and due process necessarily include the right to know how one's personal data is collected, accessed, processed, shared and used for determining civil obligations. Article 14 reinforces this because privacy and dignity cannot survive if the State can collect and process personal data without a transparent statutory framework. Article 19A reinforces it because the citizen has a constitutional right to know the basis of State action that affects him. This is not an argument against tax enforcement. It is an argument for constitutional tax enforcement. The State is entitled to know taxable income. It is entitled to detect evasion. It is entitled to use technology. But in a constitutional democracy, even legitimate objectives must be pursued through lawful, proportionate, transparent and accountable means. The absence of a comprehensive Personal Data Protection Law in Pakistan makes the problem more serious. Pakistan has had drafts of personal data protection legislation for years. The Ministry of Information Technology placed draft bills before stakeholders and continued consultations, but Parliament has not yet created a complete data protection regime governing the collection, processing, retention, correction, sharing and misuse of personal data. In the absence of such a framework, faceless tax proceedings operate in a constitutional vacuum. Comparative guidance Comparative constitutional law is useful here, not because it binds us, but because it helps us understand the direction in which modern due process is moving. Under the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation, Article 22 recognises the right not to be subjected to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, where it produces legal effects or similarly significant effects. Even where automated processing is authorised, suitable safeguards are required, including human intervention, the right to express one's point of view and the right to contest the decision. The European Commission explains the same principle in plain terms: algorithmic decisions affecting legal rights must be accompanied by safeguards. In India, the Supreme Court in K.S. Puttaswamy v Union of India [ 2017 SC 1] recognised privacy as a fundamental right and developed the idea of informational privacy and informational self-determination. Pakistan's constitutional text is fully capable of similar development through Articles 4, 10A, 14 and 19A. We do not need to import foreign law. We need to interpret our own Constitution in the light of our own digital realities. Why Pakistan's cash economy matters There is another political economy dimension that must not be ignored. Faceless audit models are usually designed for economies where commercial transactions are substantially documented and digital information is reliable. Pakistan remains a predominantly cash-based economy. Large segments of wholesale trade, retail commerce, services, construction, transport and informal enterprise continue to operate outside verifiable digital trails. Artificial intelligence can analyse only the data that exists. It cannot audit invisible cash transactions. The danger is therefore clear. The more compliant a taxpayer is, the more digital footprints he is bound to leave. The more digital footprints he leaves, the more exposed he becomes to algorithmic scrutiny. Those operating in cash may remain largely outside the same system. If this happens, technology will not broaden the tax base; it will deepen pressure on the already documented taxpayer. That will offend not only tax policy but constitutional equality and fairness. Minimum safeguards If faceless tax administration is to survive constitutional scrutiny, it must be redesigned around minimum safeguards. The taxpayer must have the right to know when personal tax data is accessed. The taxpayer must know the statutory authority under which information is collected. The taxpayer must be able to inspect his digital tax profile, subject of course to lawful limitations. The taxpayer must be allowed to challenge incorrect data and demand correction. Where algorithmic profiling is used, the broad criteria and material relied upon must be disclosed sufficiently to permit an effective defence. There must be meaningful human review before any adverse determination. There must be a personal hearing where facts, credibility, explanation or commercial reality are disputed. There must be an audit trail showing who accessed the data, when, for what purpose, and under whose authority. Finally, every order must be a speaking order. These safeguards are not obstacles to reform. They are the constitutional conditions for reform. A modern tax administration does not become weaker by respecting due process. It becomes stronger because voluntary compliance grows only where citizens trust the system. Conclusion We must therefore be clear. The debate is not technology versus Constitution. The debate is whether technology will serve the Constitution or violate it. Faceless proceedings may reduce corruption if properly structured. They may also magnify arbitrariness if left unchecked. Artificial intelligence may assist tax administration. It must never become constitutional intelligence. Algorithms may allocate cases. They cannot guarantee fairness. Data hubs may collect information. They cannot determine rights without due process. Article 10A is not confined to courtrooms. It travels wherever State power determines civil rights and obligations. When tax administration enters the digital age, the Constitution enters with it. The citizen does not lose dignity because the file becomes electronic. The taxpayer does not lose right of hearing because the officer becomes faceless. The authorised representative does not lose the right to know because the algorithm becomes confidential. My respectful conclusion is simple. A faceless tax administration cannot become a Constitution-less tax administration. Technology may modernise tax administration, but only the Constitution can legitimise it. The next frontier of Pakistani constitutional law is Digital Due Process, and it is our duty as lawyers, judges, tax professionals and citizens to ensure that the digital State remains answerable to the rule of law.

Related analysis

More Similar Posts

Budget 2027 & challenges-I

Debtocracy & Pakistan’s lost sovereignty Dr. Ikramul Haq “?.PPP’s Senator Raza Rabbani, a noted lawyer and former chairman of the Senate, termed the IMF the…

When VAT ceases to be VAT-III

Rebuilding the invoice-credit chain Dr Ikramul Haq Pakistan does not need another sales-tax reform package. It needs a decision: either restore VAT’s…

Most Viewed Posts

Reckless borrowing spree

Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori Pakistan’s economy is facing a severe and multifaceted crisis due to fiscal instability, a fragile currency, and an…

Indian Budget 2025-26

Huzaima Bukhari, Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori   The Indian economy, despite its resilience and potential, faces a multitude of challenges as it…

Massive funding plans

Huzaima Bukhari, Dr. Ikramul Haq & Abdul Rauf Shakoori   The Foreign Economic Assistance Monthly Report for November 2024 published by the Ministry of Economic…