(S.R.O. 1109(I)/2026) By
Muhammad Ashraf and Muhammad Yousha
The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has proposed one of the most significant compliance reforms for small businesses in recent years through the draft Special Procedure for Small Shopkeepers issued under section 99B of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. The proposed regime seeks to simplify tax compliance by introducing a fixed turnover-based tax, a simplified return, exemptions from certain tax obligations, and protection from routine audits.
While these incentives are expected to encourage voluntary compliance and broaden the tax base, the draft also raises important legal, drafting, and implementation issues including non-disclosure of formulae of imputed income that merit careful consideration before it is finalized. This paper highlights the key features of the proposed Special Procedure and offers comments on provisions that may require clarification or reconsideration.
This paper provides an overview of the draft Special Procedure, together with explanations and comments on its key provisions as follows:
1. Scope, Eligibility and Exclusions 2. Tax Liability and Minimum Tax Payment 3. Compliance Benefits and Exemptions 4. Easy Tax Return and Dual Filing Issues 5. Conclusion
Scope, Eligibility and Exclusions Section 99B of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 (the Ordinance) begins with a non-obstante clause, empowering the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), with the approval of the Minister- in-Charge, to prescribe a special procedure notwithstanding the other provisions of the Ordinance. In effect, the FBR has been given the discretion to prescribe a special regime in respect of matters such as:
1. Scope of application 2. Tax rates 3. Payment of tax, including fixed tax 4. Filing of income tax returns
5. Audit 6. Assessment
The expressions "small traders" and "shopkeepers" used in section 99B have not been defined in the Ordinance. In the absence of statutory definitions, these terms cannot be expanded or restricted through subordinate legislation such as a special procedure. Instead, the draft Special Procedure introduces the phrase "persons deriving income mainly through retail shops."
The inclusion of the word "retail" effectively narrows the scope of section 99B, although the parent provision itself does not impose such a restriction. It may therefore be argued that every "person" falling within the definition provided in section 80 of the Ordinance could qualify as a small trader or shopkeeper.
The draft Special Procedure further excludes several categories of persons, including: • persons whose turnover exceeded PKR 200 million in any of the preceding three tax years; • owners of multiple shops; • Tier-1 retailers; • jewellers; • retailers who filed a return for Tax Year 2025 unless the tax payable under the Special Procedure is not less than the tax payable for Tax Year 2025; and • persons who have split, divided, or renamed their business to become eligible for the Special Procedure, along with certain other specified cases.
Rule 2(ii) of the draft Special Procedure uses the phrase "shop income other sources of income," which is not clearly worded and is difficult to interpret. It appears that the FBR intends to provide that only shop income (being business income) is covered under the Special Procedure, while income from other heads recognized under the Ordinance, such as salary, property, capital gains or other sources, remains outside its scope. If this is the intended meaning, the provision should be redrafted to avoid ambiguity.
Similarly, although professional services have been excluded from the Special Procedure, such services may also be provided through premises that qualify as a shop. Therefore, excluding professional services solely by reference to the nature of the activity rather than the place of business may give rise to practical and interpretational issues.
Participation in the Special Procedure for Small Shopkeepers is voluntary. Eligible persons may either opt for this Special Procedure or continue filing their income tax returns under the normal provisions of the Ordinance. Accordingly, the eligibility criteria, exclusions and optional nature of the scheme collectively fall within the concept of "scope" contemplated by section 99B of the Ordinance.
Tax Liability and Minimum Tax Payment The draft Special Procedure proposes a tax of 1% of gross turnover, subject to a minimum cash tax payment of PKR 25,000. Accordingly, every eligible shopkeeper opting for the Special Procedure must pay at least PKR 25,000 in cash when filing the Easy Tax Return for Small Retailers (Tax Year 2026).
The draft further provides that this minimum payment must be made regardless of any tax already deducted or collected at source under the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. This includes withholding taxes deducted or collected through, among others, mobile phone bills, electricity bills, and motor vehicle transactions.
Example 1 • Tax under the Special Procedure: PKR 40,000 • Less: Withholding tax already deducted: PKR 10,000 • Net tax payable: PKR 30,000
Since PKR 30,000 is higher than the minimum amount of PKR 25,000, the shopkeeper will pay PKR 30,000.
Example 2 • Tax under the Special Procedure: PKR 35,000 • Less: Withholding tax already deducted: PKR 20,000 • Net tax payable: PKR 15,000
Since PKR 15,000 is lower than the prescribed minimum of PKR 25,000, the shopkeeper will still be required to pay PKR 25,000.
Section 99B empowers the FBR to prescribe the scope of the Special Procedure, the applicable tax rate, and the manner of payment, including the levy of a fixed tax. However, it is legally debatable whether this power extends to restricting the adjustment of withholding taxes that are neither minimum tax nor final tax under the Ordinance.
Withholding taxes that are adjustable under the general scheme of the Ordinance ordinarily constitute advance payments of income tax and are available for adjustment against the taxpayer's final tax liability. In the absence of an express statutory provision in the parent law, a Special Procedure framed through delegated legislation may not lawfully curtail this substantive right.
Accordingly, it may be argued that the non-obstante clause in section 99B, while conferring wide procedural powers, cannot be interpreted so broadly as to alter the fundamental scheme of the Ordinance relating to the adjustment of advance or adjustable withholding taxes, unless the parent statute expressly authorizes such a departure.
Compliance Benefits and Exemptions The draft Special Procedure offers several compliance and administrative benefits to eligible shopkeepers who opt into the scheme.
In general, participants will not be selected for audit. However, an audit may still be initiated where the FBR receives credible third-party information regarding significant transactions, acquisition of high-value assets, or misuse of the Special Procedure. The draft also provides that such action should be taken after consultation with the relevant trade associations.
Participants will be exempt from:
• withholding obligations under section 153 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001; • the minimum tax under section 113 at the rate of 1.25%; and • the requirement to install a Sales Tax Point of Sale (POS) system or a digital invoicing system.
As a compliance incentive, participants who fulfil the requirements of the Special Procedure will be issued an FBR QR-coded "Green Plate." While the Green Plate is prominently displayed at the business premises, FBR officers will generally refrain from entering the shop for routine tax-related matters, except where action is otherwise permitted under the Special Procedure or applicable law.
Easy Tax Return and Dual Filing Issues The draft Special Procedure includes a simplified return in Annexure-I, namely the Easy Tax Return for Small Retailers (Tax Year 2026). The return requires the disclosure of sales, purchases, expenses, profit, tax paid, and basic information relating to assets. It is proposed to be filed through the IRIS portal or the FBR mobile application.
The draft further provides that a person who neither files a regular income tax return nor opts into the Special Procedure may be liable to penalties of PKR 10,000, PKR 25,000, and PKR 50,000 for successive defaults.
The expression "Assets (Balance Sheet)" used in Annexure-I is technically inaccurate. In accounting terminology, a Balance Sheet comprises three elements: assets, liabilities, and equity (capital). Since the Annexure requires only the disclosure of assets and Capital and omits liabilities, the heading should be revised to avoid confusion.
The draft also gives rise to an important compliance issue. A shopkeeper may have income from sources other than the shop business, such as dividends, profit on debt, capital gains, rental income, or other sources of income. Such income is not covered by the Easy Tax Return.
Accordingly, these taxpayers may still be required to file a normal Return of Total Income under section 114 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, in addition to the Easy Tax Return for Small Retailers (Tax Year 2026) prescribed in Annexure-I. Where applicable, they would also remain liable to file a Wealth Statement under section 116 of the Ordinance.
As a result, many taxpayers may have to file two separate income tax returns for the same tax year, defeating one of the principal objectives of a simplified compliance regime.
It is therefore suggested that income subject to the minimum tax or final tax regimes under the Ordinance should be automatically populated in the Easy Tax Return, enabling eligible taxpayers to discharge their filing obligations through a single return. Nevertheless, taxpayers who wish to claim a refund of adjustable withholding taxes under various provisions of the Ordinance may still prefer to file the normal income tax return instead of, or in addition to, the simplified return, depending on their circumstances.
Conclusion The draft Special Procedure for Small Shopkeepers is a positive step towards broadening the tax base and simplifying tax compliance for small businesses. The proposed incentives, including exemption from audit in most cases, relief from certain tax obligations, and a simplified return, are likely to encourage voluntary compliance.
However, certain provisions require reconsideration before finalization. In particular, the undefined scope of "small traders" and "shopkeepers", the use of the term "retail", the
restriction on adjustment of withholding taxes, ambiguous drafting in certain rules, and the possibility of requiring two separate income tax returns may create legal and practical difficulties. Moreover, the formulae of imputable income should be disclosed.
Addressing these issues would make the Special Procedure more consistent with the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 and better aligned with its objective of providing a simple, fair, and effective compliance regime for small traders and shopkeepers. There are various other aspects that may be experienced by FBR in the future to come.
Mr. Muhammad Ashraf is ACCA Qualified and is an International Tax Advisor who can be accessed at taxonomy@gcctaxconsultant.com and Mr. Muhammad Yousha assists him.
