Bitter pills, missed targets Dr. Ikramul Haq Part I argued that Federal Budget 2026-27 is being shaped less by Pakistan's growth needs and more by quarterly arithmetic of International Monetary Fund's (IMF). It highlighted how the ongoing US$ 7billion 37-month Extended Fund Facility (EFF) has transformed fiscal policy into a mechanism of perpetual extraction through expanded withholding taxes, oppressive indirect taxes, and contingency mini-budget measures. Part II now examines the most embarrassing contradiction in this arrangement: despite swallowing the bitter pills prescribed by IMF-higher taxes, blocked refunds, coercive recoveries, advance collections, even when not due, and oppressive documentation drives-the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has still failed to meet even downward-revised revenue targets fixed during the ongoing EFF. The latest revenue figures expose the hollowness of the entire strategy. During July-April fiscal year 2025-26, FBR collected approximately Rs. 10.26 trillion against a target of nearly Rs. 10.95 trillion, suffering a shortfall of about Rs. 684 billion. The irony is painful: even this target was not the original one approved by Parliament. It had already been revised downward after consultations with IMF, reflecting the growing realisation that economic activity was weakening under the burden of excessive taxation and slowdown in industrial and commercial sectors. The annual target itself underwent downward revision. The original revenue target for FBR of Rs. 14.131 trillion was reduced to Rs. 13.98 trillion under IMF consultations, yet FBR still remains under immense pressure to bridge an impossible gap during the remaining two months through extraordinary recoveries, refund delays and additional taxation measures. This has converted the entire tax machinery into an instrument of panic collection rather than rational fiscal management. The situation during the first half of the fiscal year had already indicated what was coming. During July-December FY 2025-26, FBR collected around Rs. 6.729 trillion, facing a huge shortfall of over Rs. 330 billion. Even at that stage, the government was assuring IMF that the deficit would be overcome through "administrative measures", enhanced enforcement and contingency taxation. The subsequent months have proved these assurances unrealistic. As official figures just released for third quarter of current fiscal year are alarming with fiscal deficit pushed to Rs. 856.3 billion! The composition of shortfalls is even more alarming than the aggregate figures themselves. Sales tax-the largest source of indirect taxation and principal pillar of IMF's extraction strategy-has emerged as the weakest component. Collection under sales tax has substantially lagged behind targets, exposing contraction in imports, weakening industrial demand and depressed consumption. Customs duties too have suffered major deficits, confirming slowdown in trade and compression in economic activity. This is precisely what many economists and independent analysts had repeatedly warned. Excessive taxation in a stagnating economy eventually starts shrinking the very base on which taxation depends. The more the government squeezes documented sectors, the greater becomes informality, under-reporting and economic contraction. IMF's prescriptions continue to treat taxation as a purely mathematical exercise detached from production realities, business sentiment and household distress. The burden imposed during the ongoing EFF is unprecedented in Pakistan's fiscal history. Higher withholding taxes on banking transactions, dividends, profit on debt, services and commercial dealings have effectively converted the country into a withholding-tax economy rather than a genuine income-tax system. Millions of people outside taxable income thresholds continue paying advance taxes merely because they use mobile phones, banking channels or internet services. However, despite all this, the promised "revenue transformation" has not materialised. The reason is simple: taxation cannot substitute growth. A shrinking industrial sector, collapsing purchasing power and rising production costs cannot generate sustainable revenues no matter how many withholding provisions are inserted in tax statutes. The government's own conduct reveals awareness of this failure. FBR has increasingly relied upon blocking refunds, obtaining advance payments from banks and large corporations for periods not yet due, aggressive audit actions and coercive enforcement to artificially improve numbers. These tactics may temporarily inflate collections but simultaneously destroy business liquidity, discourage investment and deepen distrust between taxpayers and the state. The exporters' sector provides a classic example. Instead of facilitating export-led growth during a period of severe external vulnerability, the taxation regime has burdened exporters with multiple layers of withholding taxes, delayed refunds, minimum taxes and super taxes. Industrialists repeatedly warn that Pakistan's export competitiveness is being destroyed not merely by high energy prices but also by unpredictable and oppressive taxation. The result is stagnation in productive sectors precisely when the country desperately needs expansion in exports and manufacturing. The agricultural sector is facing similar stress. The IMF programme's contingency measures include additional Federal Excise Duty (FED) on fertilisers and pesticides in case revenue targets remain unmet. Such measures may look attractive on spreadsheets in Washington or Islamabad, but their real impact will be transmitted through rising food prices, lower agricultural productivity and higher inflation. Ordinary farmers and consumers will ultimately bear the burden, while the politically influential absentee landowners still remain substantially undertaxed. The widening Gulf conflict further complicates the situation. Pakistan's economy remains dangerously dependent on imported oil, liquified natural gas (LNG) supplies and workers' remittances from Gulf economies. Any prolonged regional instability will increase freight costs, insurance premiums and energy prices while simultaneously threatening remittance flows. In such circumstances, further indirect taxation may become economically disastrous. The IMF continues insisting on primary surplus targets without adequately recognising these geopolitical realities. This obsession with quarterly fiscal arithmetic ignores a basic principle of political economy: a weak economy cannot be stabilised through endless extraction. Fiscal consolidation without growth eventually becomes self-defeating. Pakistan's fiscal crisis is not fundamentally a revenue crisis. It is primarily a crisis of governance, wasteful expenditure and elite capture. The state continues maintaining an oversized federal structure despite the Constitution (Eighteenth Amendment) Act, 2010. Loss-making state-owned enterprises continue draining public resources. Tax expenditures and exemptions benefiting powerful lobbies remain enormous. Yet the easiest route remains taxing already documented sectors and ordinary consumers. The tragedy is that repeated IMF programmes have reinforced this flawed structure instead of dismantling it. Every programme promises "broadening of the tax base", but in practice the burden keeps shifting towards indirect and withholding taxation because politically powerful sectors remain outside meaningful taxation. The present strategy has therefore produced the worst of both worlds: economic slowdown alongside persistent fiscal stress. Even after imposing painful taxes, FBR remains unable to achieve targets. The more the targets are missed, the greater becomes pressure for mini-budgets and additional taxation. This vicious cycle is pushing the economy towards exhaustion. Pakistan urgently requires a different fiscal philosophy. Sustainable revenues can only emerge from accelerated industrialisation, export expansion, agricultural productivity, documentation through incentives rather than coercion, and restoration of taxpayer confidence. The current model of extracting more from fewer documented sectors has reached its breaking point. The repeated failure of FBR to meet even revised IMF-backed targets should serve as a warning. Excessive taxation in a low-growth economy does not produce stability. It produces stagnation, inflation, informality and public resentment. Part III will examine whether Pakistan can present an alternative growth-oriented framework to IMF based on low-rate broad-based taxation, drastic expenditure rationalisation and structural reforms capable of achieving fiscal stability without strangling economic activity. [To be continued] ___________________________________________________________________ Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.
The IMF's tax trap for budget 2026-27 series: IMF's tax trap for budget 2026-27-I
